Magazine
Google AdSense: ECJ advisory opinion brings the 1,49-billion penalty back into play
ECJ Advocate General Juliane Kokott considers the annulment of the Google AdSense penalty legally flawed. What the case has to do with publisher contracts and adtech competition.

Contents · 4 sections
A antitrust fine of 1,49 billion euros against Google could end up in court again. ECJ Advocate General Juliane Kokott recommended on 12 November 2026 that a ruling be set aside, in which the General Court of the European Union had annulled the AdSense penalty 2024. Her reasoning concerns a fundamental question of the digital advertising market: how can it be proven that the contracts of a dominant provider exclude competitors?
For publishers and advertisers, the case is therefore more interesting than the mere size of the fine. It is about the leeway a large intermediary leaves website operators when choosing competing ad providers.
What the AdSense dispute is really about
At the centre is AdSense for Search, a service that allowed websites to display search ads alongside results from their own integrated search. The operators received a share of the ad revenue. The proceedings therefore do not concern the regular ads on Google search results pages, nor directly today's programmatic display trading.
According to the findings of the EU Commission, Google used three types of contract clauses during the period 2006 to 2016: some completely excluded competing search ad providers. Others gave Google ads particularly advantageous placements and restricted the positioning of competing ads. Still others required Google's approval before changes to the ad layout.
The Commission assessed the clauses as an abuse of a dominant market position and in March 2019 imposed the fine of 1,49 billion euros. In September 2024 the EU General Court annulled the decision because, among other things, it found that the duration of the individual contractual relationships had not been sufficiently examined.
Why Kokott wants to weigh the assessment differently
Kokott considers the court's requirements for analysing contract duration to be excessive. Her approach: contracts must also be assessed in their combined effect on the market. What matters is whether the significant agreements together were capable of hindering competition. To do so, the Commission would not have to re-examine every individual contract in full detail.
This is an important shift. Anyone looking only at the wording or term of a single publisher contract may miss the effect of an entire network of contracts. It is precisely this market-wide view that Kokott wants to give greater legal weight.
The recommendation is not yet a ruling. The ECJ still has to decide; if it follows her, the case would be sent back to the General Court for fresh review. The original fine amount would probably have to be reduced, because part of the findings for 2016 is no longer being challenged.
Two Google proceedings, two different levers
In the US, a separate competition case against Google's advertising technology is running in parallel. There, the Ad Exchange AdX and the publisher ad server DFP are at the centre. In September 2026 Google was allowed to keep its business units, but under the court's conditions it must, among other things, improve access for competing systems. Srocket has already broken down the US ruling and its consequences for Prebid and publishers.
The EU AdSense case works earlier in the value chain: may a dominant intermediary contractually restrict the use of competing providers? The US case, by contrast, deals mainly with the technical interplay and the auctions of the advertising infrastructure. Both topics matter if publishers want to reduce their dependence on a single provider.
That alternatives do not arise through court rulings alone is also shown by the Prebid proposal for a new auction architecture from 2027. Technical openness, freedom of contract and real advertising demand have to come together.
What German marketing teams can take away from this
If publishers buy a search or advertising integration, they should treat exclusivity, preferred placements, approval rights for layout changes and switching options as genuine commercial terms. On the advertiser side, it pays to understand intermediary routes and available alternatives, not just the results shown in the dashboard. Our background on control and transparency in automated media buying fits here.
Whether Google ultimately has to pay again is for the courts to decide. The dispute already shows that competition in the advertising market does not begin with the bid price, but often in the contracts and technical access that come before it.
Sources: CJEU, press release 164/26 of 12 November 2026 · Digiday, 17 November 2026 · European Commission, original AdSense decision of 2019
Source


